PHI 3260 — OFFENSE AND TREATMENT
TOPICS TO GET ESSAY TWO.
Choose any ONE (and only ONE) of the topics where to write the essay, and please read the instructions on page 3 cautiously before you begin.
1 . Consider this situation:
Alf and Bob hired a motel room. The space was hired under Alf's name, and Alf purchased the 1st day's hire; the second day's rent was paid by Bob, as well as the third day's rent has not been paid. The motel director, finding the presence of his guests suspicious (long hair, colorful clothing, general air flow of disreputability), informed the authorities that this individual suspected all of them of being drug-users. The police raided the lodge room for the third working day and discovered Alf (but not Bob) asleep, and located considerable quantities of drugs and drug paraphernalia scattered regarding the room. They arrested Alf. Alf said that the medications did not are part of him but to Bob (who was nowhere fast to be found), and that even though he recognized that Joe possessed and used pot, he him self never did. Alf was prosecuted for illegal possession of medicines (which is really a criminal offence).
The question falls into 3 parts. Response all of them.
a) If you were prosecuting Alf, what arguments would you value to convince the court the act-requirement had been satisfied in such a case? b) If you were defending Alf, what arguments would you value to convince the court that the act-requirement was not satisfied in cases like this? c) If you were the judge, what would your decision become regarding this problem? Give reasons behind your answer.
2 . Consider this to be situation:
Charlie is drowning in a swimming-pool. Standing around him, not really doing anything to rescue him, are the pursuing persons, all whom will be strong swimmers: (i) Derek, who is the lifeguard working, (ii) Edwin, who is Charlie's twin close friend, (iii) Frederick, who is a great off-duty cop, (iv) Gavin, who had came across Charlie's untied shoelaces, and, in looking to keep him self from slipping, accidentally pressed Charlie in to the pool; and, (v) Harvey, a man who long meant to kill Charlie, who were passing by pool if he saw Charlie drowning, and stopped to watch.
The question declines into two parts. Answer both of them.
a) Which usually of these five witnesses to Charlie's death should be placed criminally responsible for failing to rescue Steve and which of them should not? Present reasons to rationalize your solution. b) Would it make any difference on your answer in the event Charlie took place to a paraplegic confined to a wheelchair? If perhaps so , for what reason, and if certainly not, why not?
several. Consider this condition:
Irvin and his girlfriend Jennie get drunk in their flat and begin to quarrel. Jennie threatens to beat Irvin on the brain repeatedly with a heavy cast-iron saucepan. Irvin, knowing that Jennie is fully capable of accomplishing this, flees from his apartment and into the street. A policeman finds him running across the road screaming, and takes him into custody of the children. Irvin can be prosecuted if you are drunk and disorderly within a public place, which happens to be a criminal offence.
The question is catagorized into 3 parts.
a) In the event that you where prosecuting Irvin, what argument would you value to convince the court that the voluntariness component of the act-requirement had been pleased in this case? b) If you were guarding Irvin, what argument would you use to influence the courtroom that the voluntariness component of the act-requirement was not satisfied in such a case? c) If you were the evaluate, what might your decision always be regarding this problem? Give causes of your solution.
4. Kelly is a clinically diagnosed alcohol and turns into pregnant because of a drawback in a contraceptive device. Your woman does not stay away from consuming alcohol during her pregnancy, and her child, Larry, comes into the world with severe mental reifungsverzogerung due to embrionario alcohol problem. Kelly is usually prosecuted for having caused grievous bodily problems for Larry.
Imagine mental reifungsverzogerung does in reality...